The intersection of sexual identity and religious beliefs remains complex and often contentious. LGBTQIA+ young adults raised in religious households’ face challenges that influence their sense of belonging, mental health, and identity formation. This study explores their lived experiences, focusing on how religious beliefs shape self-perception, emotional well-being, and social interactions within their families and communities. Using a narrative research design, in-depth interviews were conducted with LGBTQIA+ individuals aged 18–25 who were raised in religious households. These narratives were transcribed and analyzed using narrative analysis. Findings indicate that while participants initially perceived their homes as safe spaces, this perception changed due to familial rejection and invalidation. The internal conflict between personal identity and religious teachings led to fear of negative consequences, compelling many to conceal their identities. This study highlights the ongoing struggle for acceptance within religious family structures and the emotional toll it takes on individuals. The findings emphasize the need for open dialogue, increased awareness, and inclusive environments where LGBTQIA+ individuals can reconcile their identities with their faith. This study provides insights into the complex relationship between religion and LGBTQIA+ identities in the Philippines, underscoring the importance of fostering support systems to promote acceptance and mental well-being.